'The Old Republic'
I've played it more than a month now live, and the class quest story is really fun, but the rest is mostly WoW with a lightsaber. Still havent reached endgame yet and I'm not sure how fun it will be when I get there. For now, its still very entertaining.

Below, from the beta:
At first I had problems accepting the bad graphics, but after a while it wasn't that bothering. Since it was only a weekend beta I didn't manage to get to more than level 14. Still, it was a lot of fun, great dialog (as usual when bioware is involved), good skills and talents. Also got to try out a nice two-player "flashpoint"-instance. Definitively have potential.
Rated 9/10 on 2011-11-27